Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (2024)

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (1)

It is no secret that getting a mortgage for most people is stressful and some find it extremely difficult to obtain one.

This has created a trend of using more than one broker to get a mortgage the misconception is that if one broker fails to get a mortgage, another will.

Mortgage brokers can be invaluable for helping you get the mortgage you want, and in theory, there is no problem with engaging multiple brokers.

But there are a number of drawbacks that are often overlooked this guide looks at both the positives and negatives of using more than one mortgage broker to get your mortgage.

In this article...

  • What is a Mortgage Broker?
  • What is a Financial Adviser?
  • Can You Work with Multiple Brokers?
  • Disadvantages of Using More Than One Broker
  • Advantages of Using Multiple Brokers
  • How Do I Choose a Mortgage Broker?

What is a Mortgage Broker?

A mortgage broker is essentially a third-party adviser that can access mortgage products and provide advice specific to your circ*mstances.

Some brokers are linked directly to a single lender while others have a panel of lenders, they can place business with.

You should aim for a whole of market mortgage broker wherever possible as these mortgage brokers have access to a full range of mortgage products across the whole of the UK market.

A mortgage broker has a specific qualification called the Certificate in Mortgage Advice and Practice (CeMAP) that allows them to give you mortgage advice and process mortgage applications.

The Mortgage Broker Process

When you speak to a mortgage adviser, they will conduct a ‘fact find’ which is a questionnaire that looks at your income and expenses as well as your mortgage goals.

Once this is completed, they will take this information and compare it to products on the market looking for the mortgage that is most suitable for your situation.

After finding a product they will make a recommendation and provide a Key Facts Illustration (KFI) which outlines the mortgage they’re recommending.

If you’re happy with the product you can get a Decision in Principle (DiP).

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (2)

A DiP is a provisional acceptance from the lender to say they will accept you for a mortgage subject to application.

When searching for a property, estate agents and vendors may require a DiP if you want to make an offer on a property.

Once you have found your property, you can progress to a full mortgage application which your broker will complete on your behalf.

The broker will then oversee the mortgage application once it has been submitted and help troubleshoot any problems that crop up along the way.

Speak To A Mortgage Adviser

Free consultations are available in the UK.

Get Started Now

What is a Financial Adviser?

A financial adviser holds a different financial qualification called the Diploma for Financial Advisers (DipFA).

Part of this qualification covers a portion of the CeMAP qualification mentioned above but in order for a financial adviser to provide mortgage advice, they will still need to have completed CeMAP, or equivalent qualification, in full.

Most financial advisers opt not to complete the full CeMAP course as they prefer to provide advice around investments, pensions and other financial products.

If you’re approaching a financial adviser to arrange a mortgage the first thing you should check is that they hold the CeMAP or equivalent qualification.

Can You Work with Multiple Brokers?

You may be thinking that it makes sense to engage multiple mortgage brokers to act on your behalf.

After all, it seems logical that the more brokers you use the more likely at least one of them will be able to get you a mortgage.

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (3)

The answer to this question is yes you can use multiple brokers to act on your behalf, but the problem is, it might not help you get the mortgage you want and, in some cases, can prevent you from getting a mortgage altogether.

Disadvantages of Using More Than One Broker

The disadvantages of using multiple brokers fall into three categories:

  • Credit score problems.
  • Brokers that don’t have access to the whole of market vs those that do.
  • Potential for multiple broker fees.

There is also a fourth issue where you might receive conflicting advice which could overcomplicate the process and make deciding on the best option very difficult. This fourth issue is especially the case with both credit scoring problems and brokers with limited market access.

Credit Score Complications

When you look for a mortgage, you will be credit scored at least once during the process (upon full mortgage application).

But you may also request a DiP which lenders also perform credit score checks on.

With a typical broker process, this means you will be credit scored at least twice on your way to obtaining a mortgage.

The more brokers you use, the more you will be exposing yourself to additional credit checks.

Credit scoring by lenders is done in one of two ways a soft check (that doesn’t show on your record) and a hard check (which marks your record).

Multiple hard credit checks against your record will have a negative impact on your overall credit score.

This means that if you have approached a broker who has failed to get a mortgage and used 2 hard checks already, your new broker will likely be wary of applying for a mortgage with another hard check.

It might be the case that the lender would have accepted you without the previous hard checks but having those on the record will tell the lender you have been declined elsewhere.

When you consider mortgages are about assessing risk if a lender feels you will be an additional risk because other lenders have declined it could easily lead to further declines ultimately making it a lot more difficult to get the mortgage than it might have needed to be.

Whole of Market Brokers

A common misconception is that a whole of market mortgage broker has access to every lender on the market this is untrue in nearly all cases.

Instead, a whole of market broker has access to every mortgage option across the entire market, so whether you’re looking for a commercial mortgage, residential mortgage or bridging loan they will have at least one lender on their panel that caters for that.

When you approach a broker, it is a great idea to ask how many lenders they have on their panel as this will give you an indication of how broad their coverage is of the market.

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (4)

Limited panel or select panel brokers may only have a handful of lenders to choose from (and in some cases may be tied to a single lender).

If you find a good whole of market broker with a wide range of lenders, such as Boon Brokers, you shouldn’t need to double up advice from another broker as you will likely find the exercise fruitless.

Broker Fees

You will notice in your search for mortgage brokers that many charge what’s known as a mortgage broker fee.

A broker fee covers the advice that a mortgage broker gives.

These fees can be stacked and some charge both advice fees and then a secondary fee when you make an application.

During your initial conversation (before any advice or discussion about your mortgage occurs) a broker must outline their fees to you and at what stage they are charged.

Fees typically range from £250 to £500 but some brokers charge a lot more and we have seen broker fees up to £2000 being charged.

When you use multiple brokers that charge fees you will likely find your costs escalating needlessly as the advice received between the brokers shouldn’t be materially different.

Boon Brokers is a fee FREE whole of market mortgage, insurance and equity release broker.

By using a broker that doesn’t charge a fee and has access to a large range of lenders you have no reason to worry about employing the services of multiple brokers.

What Our Clients Have To Say

Trustpilot

Advantages of Using Multiple Brokers

In rarer circ*mstances, you may find that using more than one broker is beneficial, especially if the mortgage you’re looking to obtain is unusual or if your circ*mstances are trickier than most.

Backup for Failed Mortgage Applications

Sometimes you will find that you go through a series of different lenders with the same broker, and this can be frustrating, time consuming and in some cases costly.

A broker shouldn’t be making an application unless they have a high level of confidence that a mortgage application will be successful.

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (5)

Some brokers unfortunately don’t do enough research about lenders and make their way progressively down a list of the lenders they think will be suitable for you.

In these cases, if you have a separate broker that completes the work properly it can save you a lot of hassle and time because they will be able to find a lender that is suitable where the other broker did not.

It is important to note that once an application is submitted and a broker has looked at the criteria thoroughly, it will be out of their hands to a large degree.

That means if something untoward comes up after the application like an unknown debt or property defect, it can cause a decline without the broker having any power over the situation.

Using a reputable broker and disclosing every detail of your circ*mstances to them will help mitigate this risk and again mean you shouldn’t need to use more than one broker.

It May Be Cheaper

This might sound counter-intuitive especially if you’re using multiple brokers that charge fees.

But the fact remains that brokers have access to different lenders and products and one broker might make a recommendation that is cheapest from their panel only to be beaten by another product from the second broker.

If you have been given the details of a product from one broker and you feel it is too expensive or not to your liking in some way, you can ask that broker if that is the best product they can source.

If they confirm it is the best available to them, it is harmless to approach a fee-free broker like Boon Brokers and see if we can beat the existing product that you have been provided.

How Do I Choose a Mortgage Broker?

There are several things you should check when choosing a mortgage broker.

Are they whole of market?

It is almost always preferable to seek out a whole of market broker unless you’re specifically looking at a building society that has a product only available in your local area.

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (6)

With that said most building societies make their products (even location specific ones) available to whole of market brokers.

Are they regulated by the FCA?

Unfortunately, there are still brokers and financial advisers that operate illegally.

The FCA provides a register of all companies authorised to operate as well as a list of companies that have come to their attention for conducting business without the correct regulation.

What fees does the broker charge?

A mortgage broker in the UK must make you aware of the fees they charge BEFORE they have any kind of discussion about your situation and give any advice.

If you’re speaking over the phone this is normally part of the information they provide at the beginning of the call explaining their regulation requirements.

Most fee free brokers will also explain they don’t charge a fee for their services and explain that they’re paid a commission for arranging products.

Do they have access to DEFAQTO insurers?

This is sometimes overlooked but shouldn’t be. Brokers need to arrange insurance products often when arranging your mortgage.

Most life insurance providers are DEFAQTO rated, but some home insurance providers aren’t or have poor scores.

DEFAQTO is a body that grades insurance products out of 5 stars.

The areas they look at are important like claims pay outs and processes, product definitions (the more customer friendly the better) and also customer experience.

You may have noticed DEFAQTO scores when using comparison websites, and something that probably stands out about this is that cheaper insurers tend not to have great scores (or any scores at all).

Conclusion

Using multiple brokers can be advantageous especially if you have already used a broker that isn’t whole of market and they’re struggling to provide you with a mortgage.

But, in most cases it is best to vet your broker upfront and use a whole of market broker with an exemplary reputation.

Boon Brokers is a whole of market mortgage, insurance and equity release broker. Boon Brokers provides fee FREE mortgage advice.

Contact Boon Brokers if your current broker is unable to find a suitable mortgage for you. Or, if your existing broker charges client fees, why not check if we can offer the same product (or better) for free?

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (7)

Gerard BoonB.A. (Hons), CeMAP, CeRER

Gerard is a co-founder and partner of Boon Brokers. Having studied many areas of financial services at the University of Leeds, and following completion of his CeMAP and CeRER qualifications, Gerard has acquired a vast knowledge of the mortgage, insurance and equity release industry.

Related Articles

  • How Long Does A Mortgage Application Take?
  • What Should I Ask When Buying A House?
  • What Is A Mortgage In Principle?
  • Remortgage Or Equity Release
  • Why Buy A Home In Norwich?
  • Equity Release Horror Stories
  • How To Avoid Early Repayment Charges
  • Advantages Of A Mortgage Broker
  • How Long Does A Mortgage Application Take?
  • The House Buying Process
  • What Is A 100% Mortgage
  • Preparing For An Interest Rate Rise

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (8)Authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. No: 973757

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (9)

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (10)

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (11)

Working With Multiple Mortgage Brokers at the Same Time (2024)

FAQs

Is it worth talking to multiple mortgage brokers? ›

Contact at least three lenders on your list. Don't stop with just one lender! By exploring your options with multiple lenders, you get more information about your options and get a sense for which loan officers you might feel most comfortable working with.

Can I work with two mortgage brokers at the same time? ›

When you apply for a mortgage, working with two or more lenders at once can help you find the best deal. However, what you don't want is to end up paying multiple fees for multiple applications. For example, if you get far enough into the process of a mortgage application, you will need to pay for an appraisal.

What is the disadvantage of working with a mortgage broker? ›

A Broker May Not Source the Best Deal for You

Many home buyers simply assume that a broker can deliver a better deal than they could get on their own, but this is not always the case. Some lenders may offer home buyers the very same terms and rates that they offer mortgage brokers (sometimes, even better).

Can you go through underwriting with two lenders? ›

“There will be a record of multiple credit inquiries if you do apply with multiple lenders, but there should be little to no impact on your credit score from those inquiries and it shouldn't discourage you from speaking with multiple lenders until you find the right fit,” says Anastasio.

Is it OK to work with multiple brokers? ›

One of the major benefits of working with multiple brokers is the ability to get various experts giving you their dynamic views to risk while at the same time being able to get the most competitive rate and at the best price. The most effective way to work with multiple brokers is to assign markets to each broker.

Should you work with multiple brokers? ›

Working with multiple brokers can diversify your trading options and reduce your risks. You can compare and choose the best brokers for different markets, products, strategies, and conditions.

Do multiple pre approvals affect credit score? ›

That means your credit score will take a small hit each time (usually less than 5 points on your FICO score). If you get preapproved multiple times within a few weeks — which can happen when you're shopping for mortgage rates — only one hard inquiry will count against your credit score.

Do multiple mortgage inquiries count as one? ›

Within a 45-day window, multiple credit checks from mortgage lenders are recorded on your credit report as a single inquiry. This is because other lenders realize that you are only going to buy one home. You can shop around and get multiple preapprovals and official Loan Estimates.

Do multiple loan applications hurt your credit? ›

However, applying for two different types of loans, for example, a student loan and a car loan within a two-week period can count as two separate hard inquiries. Applying for more loans after the timeframe of 14 to 45 days can negatively impact your credit score.

How many mortgage brokers fail? ›

As we all know the statistics on starting a new business are quite staggering – almost half will fail within the first 2 years – Mortgage Broking is no different. Even the fastest starters will experience a period of months before the first revenue flows are received.

Is a mortgage broker a stressful job? ›

First, the job can be stressful. Mortgage brokers are often working with tight deadlines, and they need to be able to handle a lot of paperwork. Second, the job can be competitive. There are many mortgage brokers ,so it can be difficult to stand out from the crowd.

Is it better to use a mortgage broker or do it yourself? ›

The decision to use a broker depends on your personal circ*mstances and preferences. Brokers can save you time and effort, and they might be able to secure a better deal than you could find on your own, especially if there's a chance you might be turned down by lenders.

How common is it to get denied during underwriting? ›

You may be wondering how often underwriters denies loans? According to the mortgage data firm HSH.com, about 8% of mortgage applications are denied, though denial rates vary by location and loan type. For example, FHA loans have different requirements that may make getting the loan easier than other loan types.

How often do mortgages fall through during underwriting? ›

How often do mortgages fall through during underwriting? According to the most recent data from the Consumer Financial Credit Bureau, home purchase application denial rates were 8.3% in 2021, lower than in 2020 (9.3%) and 2019 (8.9%). As you can see, the statistics are fairly low, but it can still happen.

Can a bank override an underwriter? ›

Policy and underwriting exceptions are conditions in approved loans that contravene the bank's lending policies or underwriting guidelines. In an automated approval environment, policy exceptions should be rare. However, if the underwriting process includes a judgmental element, overrides are more likely to occur.

Should you meet with multiple lenders? ›

Applying to multiple mortgage lenders allows you to compare rates and fees to find the best deal. Having multiple offers in hand provides leverage when negotiating with individual lenders.

Is it best to talk to mortgage broker or bank? ›

he choice between a mortgage broker and a bank depends on your personal preferences and needs. Mortgage brokers can offer more loan options because they work with multiple lenders. Banks, on the other hand, provide their own loan products but may have more rigid guidelines.

When should you start talking to a mortgage broker? ›

The moment you think about buying a home is when you should be talking to a lender,” Rueth says. “You don't have to already be in the process of buying a home to do this. You can be two years away from buying a home and still start that conversation.”

Is it worth speaking to a mortgage advisor? ›

Whether you're buying a property or just remortgaging, mortgage advice can be a great help. Taking independent advice can make the difference between a successful mortgage application and being rejected. It may also lead to a better deal, potentially saving you thousands of pounds over the mortgage term.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Allyn Kozey

Last Updated:

Views: 5988

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (43 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Allyn Kozey

Birthday: 1993-12-21

Address: Suite 454 40343 Larson Union, Port Melia, TX 16164

Phone: +2456904400762

Job: Investor Administrator

Hobby: Sketching, Puzzles, Pet, Mountaineering, Skydiving, Dowsing, Sports

Introduction: My name is Allyn Kozey, I am a outstanding, colorful, adventurous, encouraging, zealous, tender, helpful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.